Rdio is my current (de jour) music streaming service . I was using Slacker Radio, but I’ve switched to Rdio and I vastly prefer it. Being located in Canada, the options for streaming music services are pretty limited, but generally speaking I’m quite happy with Rdio (although I get pretty annoyed with the number of albums not available in Canada… probably about 1/4-1/3 of the total I search for).
Rdio has been infamously cagey about what kind of quality they are delivering. They say that their iPhone app uses a higher bitrate stream when on WIFI, compared to 3G, and they claim that the web and Adobe AIr application have “
CD Quality” streams. For comparison,
Chris Breen suggests that many of the competitors offer between 128kB/s to 320 kB/s (320 kB/s LAME encoded MP3s are generally considered “transparent”, that is, indistinguishable from CD quality sound).
NOTE: Chris Breen’s article says that Rdio uses 320kB/s streams, but my results (below) differ substantially.
Generally speaking, I think Rdio streams are
acceptable. I’ve got something of a tin ear, and a decent but by no means audiophile setup (T-amp with Mission 700 Leading Edge speakers, streamed through Apple Airport Express), and I don’t feel like I’m missing much. Yet, in the interest of science, I conducted a quick real world bitrate test. Using
Wild Nothing’s Gemini album, on my Rogers 25mB/s cable connection, over WIFI (B/G class) I monitored my network traffic using
Codebox Software’s BitMeter OS application.
Here’s the results (I’ll continue to monitor the stream, and if it looks like these are unusual results I will post an update):
The bitstream spikes and then drops way down, pretty consistently, and averages just under 40kB/s!
Posted via email from T H I N K | Comment »